Many assume gas leaks and carbon monoxide buildup are one and the same, but confusing the two can leave you vulnerable. When comparing a carbon monoxide vs gas leak, the key lies in understanding their unique sources, symptoms, and warning triggers.
This guide cuts through the confusion to explain how to spot each threat early and how to respond safely before a minor issue becomes a major emergency
Because natural gas has no smell naturally, suppliers add a chemical called mercaptan to give it the familiar rotten egg odour—so, you’ll notice a strong smell before anything else.
You may also hear a faint hissing sound near a gas pipe or appliance, or notice that gas appliances are not performing as they should. Carbon monoxide is a colourless, odourless, and tasteless gas produced when gas appliances don’t burn fuel completely.
Carbon monoxide can be produced by:
Because there is no warning smell, many people don’t realise they’re being exposed until symptoms start occurring like headaches, dizziness, nausea, fatigue, shortness of breath, and confusion
As exposure increases, symptoms become more severe and may lead to unconsciousness or even death. A key clue is that symptoms often improve after leaving the building and return when you go back inside.
The easiest way to understand the difference is that a gas leak happens when natural gas escapes from a pipe or appliance before it burns. Meanwhile, a carbon monoxide (CO) is produced when gas burns incorrectly because of poor combustion.
In other words, one is unburnt gas, while the other is a poisonous by-product of burning gas.
While both hazards involve gas appliances, they present very differently. Here’s a simple comparison to help you understand the key differences.
| Feature | Gas Leak | Carbon Monoxide |
| Can you smell it? | Yes (rotten egg smell) | No |
| Can you see it? | No | No |
| Produced before or after burning? | Before combustion | During incomplete combustion |
| Common cause | Escaping natural gas | Faulty or poorly ventilated appliances |
| Main danger | Fire and explosion | Poisoning |
| Detection | Your sense of smell and gas leak testing | Carbon monoxide detector |
When it comes to gas systems, a minor glitch can quickly turn into a major safety hazard. Get in touch with a qualified technician right away if
Licensed gas plumber can provide expert leak detection, repairs, and comprehensive gas safety checks across the entire Melbourne area. Taking action early is always the safest way to protect your property!
No. A gas leak involves unburnt natural gas escaping from the system, while carbon monoxide is a poisonous gas created when fuel burns incompletely.
No. Carbon monoxide has no smell, colour, or taste. That’s why carbon monoxide detectors are strongly recommended.
Most people describe it as a strong rotten egg or sulphur smell because natural gas suppliers add an odourant to help people detect leaks quickly.
Yes. A faulty appliance may leak natural gas while also producing carbon monoxide because it isn’t burning fuel correctly.
Turn off your gas supply if it is safe, leave the property, and contact a licensed gas plumber immediately. If there’s an immediate risk to life or a major gas emergency, contact your gas distributor’s emergency line and emergency services where appropriate.
Understanding the difference between a gas leak and carbon monoxide could prevent a dangerous situation from becoming far worse.
While gas leaks are usually detectable by smell, carbon monoxide offers no warning at all, making regular servicing essential.
If you suspect a gas leak, your appliances aren’t performing properly, or it’s simply time for a safety inspection, book your gas safety inspection with Melbourne Gas Plumber today.
Every week, we share practical insights based on the combined knowledge and real-world experience of our team. Our articles cover gas fitting, gas safety, appliance installation, hot water systems, maintenance and everyday plumbing issues, so you can make well-informed decisions about your gas plumbing needs.
Fill the form below and we’ll get back ASAP!
MGP! Thank you for help, honest pricing and high quality work. Thank you to Joe for pricing and the boys involved for replacing my hot water tank and fixing my gas leak for a reasonable price. 5 star response, 5 star service and 5 star price.
Joe was great. Very professional and quick. Gas hot water heater needed replacing, he was honest and upfront about what our options were. System was sourced and replaced within a couple of hours.
Fantastic service very responsive Joe is highly recommended and works very clean and neat..... good job well done....very happy... will use again and again
At Melbourne Gas Plumber, we're here to handle all your gas plumbing needs throughout Melbourne. With over 40 years of experience, we bring extensive local knowledge and expertise to every job.
QUICK LINKS
OPENING HOURS
Open 24/7
